The Right and Wrong Way to Feed Deer This Winter | Bone Collector

The Do’s and Don’ts of Feeding Deer This Winter

Supplemental Feeding Deer | The Right and Wrong Way to Feed Deer This Winter

Old man winter has shown mercy this year, and both the deer and hunters are grateful! With that being said, we still have the rest of February and March to get through before “green life” returns to our neck of the woods. Once spring does arrive, turkey fans won’t be the only thing we see shoot up. Fresh protein rich food sources will also spring up, and once again flourish in the hardwoods and in our food plots. While the country is still in old man winter’s frozen grip, this spring green up is in sight and with it, the end of a 4 month long struggle for life. Deer are hurting right now, maybe not as bad as previous years, but don’t let the lack of snowfall fool you. It is this struggle that we hunters start to become concerned about this time of year and as a result, we naturally feel obligated to intervene. This intervention is often in the form of a bag of “deer corn”, and it could spell disaster for you. Feeding deer during the winter is not a subject to lightly dismiss as a “common sense subject”, there is a right way and a wrong and in some situations fatal way to do it. To understand every piece that is required before feeding deer during the winter, we first need to take a walk in the shoes of a whitetail.

Walk a Season in the Whitetail’s Shoes

Imagine if you will, you’re a hog of a buck, one of those southern Iowa whoppers we all know exist. Its late October your busy eating acorns and stacking up the energy and carbs before the rut, putting on the pounds of fat. You feel your testosterone rising and those little bucks are really pestering you. Once November rolls around your weight is at an astonishing 255 pounds! You’re having fun running does throughout the southern Iowa corn fields and hardwoods, occasionally locking one down in your favorite thicket. It’s all fun and games until that first snowflake falls, then it’s back to survival. Now let’s fast forward to late February, you now weigh 180 pounds, you have shed your antlers, your fat reserves are almost spent, there is no corn left in the fields, and the snow is a foot deep. You need energy and protein to repair your body condition after the long rut. The worst news is that your instincts understand new food isn’t coming anytime soon, and more winter is still likely to be had!

From any deer hunters perspective this buck basically seems to be up “you know which creek,” right? Absolutely, and it’s not just the buck, every whitetail in the woods struggles in late February and March. The skinny, rut-worn buck, the pregnant nanny, and the 8-9 month old fawn are all in trouble. Don’t get us wrong, deer are given the correct tools to survive winter, a thick insulated coat, an internal computer telling them what and when to eat, and the knowledge to find food and a warm bed in tough conditions. Even with all of these tools the facts still remain, a whitetail is running out of fat reserves, food sources are slim, and there is still a month to go before the buffet opens. Out of time and out of options, supplemental feeding seems to be the golden ticket for our deer herds. Unfortunately this ticket could be real and helpful…or a trap and fatal, all depending on you, your area, and your situation!

The Big Concern of Feeding Deer in the Winter

East to west, states across the country have restrictions or have outlawed baiting and feeding deer …as much as you hate to hear it. Why? A lot focuses around deer to deer transmission of diseases, such as Chronic Wasting Disease. However, in the winter, disease within a deer can develop. It’s called Acidosis, the fatal and ugly side of improper supplemental feeding! When ruminants (deer) get ahold of large quantities of carbohydrates that are low in fiber, not normally not found in their diet this time of year, they lack the microorganisms in their stomach to digest the food. Adjustments in the stomach are made within 6 hours of digesting large amounts of this food source (commonly corn) changing the makeup of the stomach entirely, leading to a flush of lactic acid. This results in a fall of pH, destruction of the digestion and absorption process, and eventual dehydration and death of the deer! This is the number one, big concern over feeding deer during the winter. Now before you comment with your opinions on the subject, and say that we are against feeding, finish this article through and get all the information.

Feeding Deer This Winter | Bone Collector

Supplemental Feeding Deer | Bone Collector

 

 

With this information it’s a wonder how there are any deer in the Midwest at all! “With all that corn laying in the fields after harvest any one of those states are giant minefields just waiting to kill deer” – this type of statement is exactly why the subject takes some explaining. Photoperiods tell a whitetail’s internal computer to restrict movement, eat less, and also suggests what to eat. A deer will rely on its fat reserves for most of their bodily functions and energy requirements, but they do still need to eat. Their diet consists mostly of woody browse this time of year, early successional species like blackberries and greenbriers, and saplings. This diet is high in fiber and the microflora in a deer’s gut are adjusted for this type of diet. But, deer in areas like the Midwest (and other properties or areas with large scale Ag) are locked on corn as a primary food source from November till the last kernel is gone in the field – usually in February or spring green up in some situations. In those situations deer and their stomachs will not bat an eye over a sudden corn pile in the woods. But in areas without the corn food source consistently availability, the corn pile could spell disaster!

So with this information you can now determine whether or not your neighbors feeding deer in their backyard are killing their “pets.” So yeah…now might be the time to break the news to that old, kind-hearted couple across the street. But be cautious…they might be smarter than they look! You can be successful at feeding deer during the winter by using the right type of feed and at the right amount.

How to Feed Deer During Winter

Let’s briefly return to the deer’s gut again. If a sudden switch of food sources is bad, how do they naturally switch from a food source like acorns to corn, then back from corn to woody browse…without problems? It’s all about the timing and amount.

If feeding and baiting in your state is legal, and you have been feeding all year long, then you are good to go. For those just starting to feed now, you need to pay attention! You can introduce a new food source in small amounts (around 10lbs over a period of a couple days, more or less according to deer density) successfully. The right type of deer feed still needs to be addressed but for now let’s stick to the right amount.

The deer’s gut flora need anywhere from a week to 3 weeks to adjust to a new type of diet. Small amounts of the new food source will not cause a sudden shock and switch, resulting in a negative pH change and death. If the deer on your property are only given small and increasing amounts of the new food source over a long period of time, the gut flora will adjust and the introduction will be successful. Now for you this is bad news. Your family, day job, and other obligations will keep you from properly introducing small amounts of feed on your property. Are you really going to spread a half a bucket of feed out every 2 days? What makes more sense is investing in a feeder. Feeders will allow you to control the when and how much without spending your valuable time. Increasing spread time, amount, and refilling the feeder every other weekend sounds more manageable. But this introduction will fail if you use the wrong feed.

The Best Deer Feed for Winter

Quiz time, what food source consists more than 60% of a whitetail’s diet right now? How about woody browse like saplings, briars, and honeysuckle! That’s right, it is the correct feed for this time of year. But you can’t supplement those types of foods when times get hard, it’s more of a long term management process.

However, with the best deer feed for the winter being woody browse, our feed needs to be similar. At least in nutritional make up. Loading the feeder up with corn is not going to cut it. Did you forget? You’re that hog of a buck in southern Iowa. You’re worn out and need protein and energy to repair recover your body condition and carry out normal everyday functions. Woody browse give you this, corn does not. The correct feed needs to supply the right amount of protein, fat, and that crucial fiber factor for similarity with woody browse.

Feeds such as Big and J BBGranular work this time of year. The product has the following analysis:

COMPONENT MIN MAX
Crude Protein 18.0% –                 –               –
Crude Fat 8.0% –                 –               –
Crude Fiber –                 –              – 7.0%
Calcium 0.8% 1.3%
Phosphorus 0.7% –                 –               –
Salt 0.25% 0.50%
Sodium –                 –               – 0.50%

Supplemental Deer Feeding | Bone Collector

Protein…check, fat…check, fiber…check. This feed is more easily digestible and meets the nutritional requirements by also supplying the two most prevalent and studied minerals in deer, Calcium and Phosphorous.

By supplying the right type of feed for deer and at the right amount with using a feeder, starting a supplemental feed program in winter can be successful. By paying attention here you eliminate the biggest concerns of feeding deer during the winter.

Supplemental Feeding Tips

If you batting around the idea of starting a feeding program this winter, you are already looking into the fine and detailed aspects on your deer hunting property. If you decide in favor of starting a program (given it is legal), you can take it to the next level. If hunting over bait is legal in your area you already have the idea, if not take note of these supplemental feeding tips.

  • Food- taking the supplemental feeding program beyond just the feed, placing the feed or feeder near or next to a food plot, creates an extremely attractive food source, at least one that beats out the neighbor’s food plot.
  • Water- having a food plot, a feeder, and a water source is just supplying one more essential need, giving them even more of a reason to stick around.
  • Block – another added attraction to this micro area, the Big and J Deer Cube supplies just that…with the added nutrient and mineral advantage.
  • Cover – by now you are getting the idea. A whitetails life is a survival game, and in survival three big things are key, food, water and shelter. By providing quality cover and a sanctuary close to the feed, food plot, water, and block attraction, you know have a deer hunting hotpot.
  • Trail Camera – This is obvious, with all this attraction it sure is advantageous spot for a Bushnell Trail Camera.

With every aspect of a deer’s needs supplied in this micro area, you have essentially created one of the best bow hunting sets imaginable. If hunting over bait is not legal you will need to be sure the feeder and block and any traces of them are gone before the season starts. Also being sure to keep the pressure minimal with proper scent control will keep the spot hot.

Other Considerations

Before feeding deer during winter and starting a supplemental feeding program, a lot needs to be considered. Other than acidosis, numerous states put restrictions on feeding and baiting deer due to other negatives associated with supplemental feeding. Ever heard of Chronic Wasting Disease? That’s a big one. Concentrating deer to feed or mineral sites can increase the chance of nose to nose contact and spread of disease. Other than the spread of disease, potential increased deer traffic can wreak havoc on the local habitat, making resources such as woody browse scarce. A feeder placed next to some thick vegetation also makes for the perfect ambush point for predators. Overall these negatives can be avoided by habitat improvements, doe management, and predator control, ultimately making the benefits far outweighing the negatives.

Make an informed decision. Take a walk on your property or hire a deer and habitat biologist to assess whether or not you need to start a feeding program. A good place to start is a trail camera survey and browse impact study get a grasp of you deer population and its effect on the habitat.

Supplemental feeding of deer in the winter can give life, or take it away. It all depends on the area and your situation. Take the time to look into this topic in depth before you start feeding deer in your backyard. You might do more harm than good, or more good than harm.

10 replies
  1. Felipe Miranda
    Felipe Miranda says:

    What you think about using molasses.
    I mostly hunt in a public land and can’t do the food plot n even put a trail camera cux they migth stole it.
    I got spot kinda close to the water source.

    What you recommend me to use for feed the deer.

    Reply
    • Brian
      Brian says:

      If you can get the same spot everyday, carry a plastic coffee can full of corn and acorns in your backpack and spread it near where the deer are coming past. Once they find it more than once, you can move where you spread it to where you will have a good shot. This has worked great for me. I spread 1 full can every 3 days. I even dropped a few drops of doe urine to make them feel safer.

      Reply
      • Lisa Williams
        Lisa Williams says:

        Our game warden informed me of these conditions last year. I have since changed my winter feeding habits. Great info!!!

        Reply
  2. Poppie
    Poppie says:

    I have been reading articles on wildlife feeding for a while now. I did not get it until I read this one. I get it. Don’t feed sumer food in winter. Duh. Most of our agencies just say “you are not helping”. Thank you for the real life perspective.

    Reply
  3. kathryn schultz
    kathryn schultz says:

    is it ok to feed white tail deer a mix of mgm and alfalfa pellets or corn and alfalfa pellets every day ? i don’t know how many deer eat out of the 5 containers i put out not lg. containers. we live in a small city in north east washington 40 miles from canada so we get quite a bit of snow and very cold weather snow stays heavy some winters. we see moms with last summer fawns lone doe’s and 2 or 3 deer in a group sometimes a young buck or 2. we don’t hunt just try to help the deer.

    Reply
  4. Jerry Cobb
    Jerry Cobb says:

    What do you think of feeding roared soy beans. The deer love it, and the coons and bear won’t eat it.

    Reply
  5. Lynn
    Lynn says:

    I want to attract and feed the deer on my property just to watch them. No killing them. Can you tell me briefly the best way to do that? I definitely don’t want to put out something that will hurt them.
    Thanks!

    Reply
  6. Bruce Stamile
    Bruce Stamile says:

    I want to thank you for the article on feeding deer in winter… I probably never would have done it your way which is the right way… It could have been a disaster… Now onto hunting………
    I quit hunting quite a few years ago……………
    It makes me SICK when I see how people hunt today…. Baiting of animals…. Tree stands…. scent repellent…. wearing camo…. this is more like entrapment than hunting…. Why not walk the woods with your rifle and rely on your cunning and perseverance of tracking down the prey … that’s the sport of it… What’s being done today is really a sick…sick type of execution…. Not hunting

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *